Skip to main content
★★★★★ 4.9 on Google · 4.99/5 on TrustATrader
  • Available 24/7

Flat Roofing

EPDM vs GRP vs Felt: Which Flat Roof Is Best for Your London Extension?

EPDM vs GRP vs Felt: Which Flat Roof Is Best for Your London Extension?

If your flat roof is leaking, holding puddles, or simply coming to the end of its life, you’ll quickly run into three options: EPDM rubber, GRP fibreglass and torch-on felt. Every roofer has a favourite, and some will push whichever system is quickest for them to install that week.

This guide is the straight version. It’s based on the extensions, side returns, dormers and garages we work on every week across South London, South West London and Surrey, and it covers what each material is good at, what it costs here, and which one actually suits your roof.


The Short Answer

SystemTypical lifespanBest forOur guarantee
EPDM rubber25–30+ yearsSimple extension and garage roofs10 years
GRP fibreglassAround 20 yearsBalconies, walked-on roofs, complex shapes10 years
Torch-on felt10–15 yearsGarages, sheds, tighter budgets5 years

For most London kitchen extensions and side returns, EPDM or GRP is the better long-term spend. Felt still has a place, but it’s rarely the right choice over a heated room you care about.


EPDM Rubber: The Long-Life All-Rounder

EPDM is a single sheet of synthetic rubber, laid in one piece across the whole roof. Because there are no seams across the main area, there are far fewer places for water to eventually find a way in.

Where it shines: straightforward rectangular roofs such as rear extensions, side returns, single-storey outriggers and garages. Rubber also copes well with the daily expansion and contraction of a roof deck through hot summers and freezing winter nights.

Where to be careful: EPDM isn’t designed for regular foot traffic, so it’s not our first choice for a balcony or a roof you’ll be stepping out onto. Very fiddly roofs with lots of upstands and penetrations take more skill to detail neatly in rubber.

GRP Fibreglass: Hard-Wearing and Walkable

GRP is a liquid resin reinforced with glass matting. It’s laid on site and cures into one rigid, seamless surface, with a hard top coat that can be walked on.

Where it shines: balconies, roof terraces, dormer cheeks and roofs with awkward shapes, because it’s formed in place and can be taken up and around details. It also gives a very clean, finished look.

Where to be careful: GRP needs dry weather and the right temperature to cure properly, so installation is more weather-dependent. It’s also less forgiving of a deck that moves, so the timber base underneath has to be solid and properly prepared.

Torch-On Felt: The Budget Option

Modern multi-layer torch-on felt is a big step up from the old three-layer felt that covered most 1960s and 70s extensions, but it’s still the shortest-lived of the three, typically lasting 10–15 years.

Where it makes sense: garages, sheds, outbuildings and situations where you need a sound roof without spending more than the building justifies.

Where we’d steer you away: over a kitchen, bedroom or any heated room where a leak would do real damage. Over the life of the roof, felt often costs more because it needs replacing sooner.


What Flat Roofs Cost in London

As a guide, a standard single garage flat roof replacement typically costs £800–£2,500, depending on size, material and access. Larger flat roofs on extensions, side returns and dormers typically run £2,800–£7,000, depending on the system used.

For smaller repair work, per-square-metre rates in South London typically run around £115–£175 for felt, £138–£212 for EPDM and £150–£225 for GRP. Two things push the price up: a rotten deck that has to be replaced once the old covering comes off, and bringing insulation up to current standards. We’ll always price those clearly before any extra work starts. Our roof repair cost guide has the full breakdown.


The Mistake That Matters More Than the Material

The most common reason a flat roof fails isn’t the covering at all. It’s fall, the slight slope built into the roof so water runs off instead of sitting on it.

If you always see a puddle in the same spot after rain, the roof doesn’t have enough fall in that area. Water that sits there day after day will eventually work its way through any material. Re-covering the roof without correcting the fall just means the same puddle, and eventually the same leak, comes back. Before we recommend a material, we check whether the roof actually drains.

Warm Roof or Cold Roof?

When a flat roof is replaced, it’s worth deciding how it’s insulated:

  • Warm roof: insulation sits on top of the deck, under the waterproof layer. This largely removes the risk of condensation and is usually the better long-term choice over a heated room.
  • Cold roof: insulation sits between the joists under the deck. It’s cheaper, but more prone to condensation forming underneath, which can lead to damp and rot over time.

If more than about a quarter of the roof is being replaced, Building Regulations usually expect the insulation to be upgraded at the same time where it’s practical, so it’s worth planning for.


So Which Should You Choose?

  • Kitchen extension or side return you want to forget about: EPDM, on a warm roof build-up.
  • Balcony, roof terrace or a roof you’ll walk on: GRP.
  • Dormer or awkward-shaped roof: usually GRP, sometimes EPDM depending on the detailing.
  • Garage or shed on a budget: modern torch-on felt is a sensible option.

We’ll recommend based on your roof’s size, use and budget, not whichever system is easiest for us to install.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can my existing flat roof be repaired instead of replaced? Often, yes. If the damage is in one area and the falls and deck are sound, a repair can add years at a fraction of the cost. We’ll tell you honestly at the free inspection.

How long does a new flat roof take? Most garage and extension roofs are done in 1–3 days, weather permitting. GRP needs dry conditions to cure, so it’s more weather-dependent.

Could my old garage roof contain asbestos? Corrugated cement sheets on garages built before the early 2000s can. Don’t drill, cut or pressure-wash it. If it needs removing, that’s done by a licensed specialist as a separate cost.


Get a Straight Answer on Your Flat Roof

Free inspection, no call-out fee, and a written quote with everything included up front. Every EPDM and GRP roof we install carries a 10-year guarantee, and felt carries 5 years. See our flat roofing and garage roof pages, or call or WhatsApp 07455 632326 for a same-day response across South London, South West London and Surrey.

Keep Reading

More Roofing Advice

Want A Straight Answer On Your Roof?

Free quotes, no call-out fee, and a written price with scaffolding, VAT and waste removal included up front.

Call or WhatsApp 07455 632326 for a same-day response across South, South West and West London and Surrey.